By Jim Lineweaver, CFP®, AIF®
The first year without a salary can produce an unfamiliar sight: a tax return showing much less income than you earned while working. For someone with a substantial IRA, that quieter year may offer a chance to address a future tax bill.
Roth conversion strategies can help you use that opportunity, provided the upfront cost supports your longer-term plans. The decision comes down to whether paying tax now leaves you or your family better positioned later, and how much you can convert without creating other problems.
What Is a Roth Conversion?
A traditional IRA to Roth IRA conversion moves existing retirement assets into a Roth account. You generally pay ordinary income tax on the previously untaxed amount, while future qualified withdrawals can be tax-free under IRS conversion rules.
A conversion differs from an annual contribution. A backdoor Roth strategy combines a nondeductible IRA contribution with a conversion, rather than simply converting an existing pretax balance. Here, the focus is on deciding what to do with retirement savings you already own.
When Does a Roth Conversion Make Sense?
A conversion deserves consideration when the tax cost today looks favorable compared with the tax you or your beneficiaries might otherwise pay. Your expected income, spending needs, and ability to leave the converted money invested all influence that comparison.
A large IRA deserves particular attention because Roth IRAs do not require lifetime RMDs for their original owners. Converting some traditional IRA assets can reduce the balance that generates future required minimum distributions. However, avoiding those withdrawals has value only if the conversion cost makes sense.
Before Retirement
During peak earning years, salary, bonuses, and executive compensation may make a conversion expensive. Waiting could give you access to a lower tax rate, although a career break or unusually low bonus might create an earlier opening.
If you plan to move, compare state taxes as well. A conversion shortly before relocating to a lower-tax state could cost more than waiting.
After Retirement
A Roth conversion after retirement may fit during the years between your final paycheck and the start of Social Security or RMDs. Those years often give you more control over taxable income.
Check what actually lands on the tax return, though. Severance, deferred compensation, investment gains, and IRA withdrawals for living expenses can fill that apparent opening. Your first year of retirement transition planning may look very different from your second.
Roth Conversion Strategies for Choosing an Annual Amount
Start with a tax projection before selecting a conversion amount. Then compare several amounts across multiple years, allowing for pensions, future withdrawals, spending, and changes in filing status.
Filling the remaining space in a tax bracket can provide a starting point. It should not become an automatic target, because the next dollar of conversion income can affect costs beyond its stated tax rate.
For example, conversion income can increase the taxable portion of Social Security benefits. It can also push some long-term capital gains into a higher rate or reduce income-based deductions.
Medicare adds a delayed expense. Social Security generally uses income from two years earlier to calculate income-related Medicare premiums. A conversion at age 63 can therefore affect premiums at 65. Evaluate the thresholds for the affected premium year rather than assuming today’s thresholds will apply.
A Roth conversion can affect your retirement income, taxes, and long-term financial goals. Learn how coordinated wealth planning can help you evaluate conversion strategies alongside your family’s financial needs.
How to Pay the Conversion Tax
Cash outside retirement accounts can help you pay the bill while preserving the amount you convert. Using IRA money for taxes leaves less invested and may trigger an additional early-distribution tax if you are under 59½ and no exception applies. Selling appreciated investments to raise cash can add another tax cost.
Your tax advisor should also review whether you need estimated payments or additional withholding. Waiting until you file could leave you facing an underpayment penalty.
What Three Conversion Amounts Could Look Like
Consider a hypothetical married couple, both 63, who have fully retired. Their $3 million includes $2 million in pretax IRAs, $800,000 in taxable investments and cash, and $200,000 in Roth IRAs.
They expect $132,200 in ordinary income from pension payments, investments, and planned IRA withdrawals, enough to cover $120,000 of annual spending and baseline federal income tax. They have postponed Social Security and hold $100,000 in cash for conversion taxes beyond their spending reserve.
Assume they file jointly in 2026, take the $32,200 standard deduction, and hold no after-tax IRA basis. Their federal taxable income before conversion equals $100,000. Using the 2026 federal tax brackets, the immediate comparison looks like this:
| Conversion amount | Federal taxable income | Additional federal income tax |
| $0 | $100,000 | $0 |
| $40,000 | $140,000 | $8,720 |
| $120,000 | $220,000 | $26,492 |
This simplified illustration holds deductions constant and excludes state taxes, capital gains, credits, and Medicare costs. It assumes they pay conversion taxes from existing cash without selling investments.
These Roth conversion strategies create different near-term costs. The smaller conversion uses less cash and recognizes less income. The larger conversion moves more assets into Roth accounts, but some income reaches the 24% bracket and could increase future Medicare costs. Neither amount proves superior without comparing future taxes and spending. Choosing no conversion also deserves a place in that projection.
When Converting May Be a Poor Choice
If you expect substantially lower tax rates later, paying today’s rate may offer little benefit. A conversion can also strain the plan when you need the money soon or would have to spend your emergency reserve to cover taxes.
Charitable intentions can change the calculation. Before converting money you intend to leave to a qualified charity, compare the result with keeping those assets in a traditional IRA. Coordinating charitable giving and tax planning may point toward a different use for that account.
Family circumstances deserve equal attention. A surviving spouse may eventually file as single and face different tax brackets, while adult children may inherit during their highest earning years. Roth assets can offer flexibility, although beneficiary distribution rules still apply. Compare the family’s likely tax costs before deciding how much to convert.
Before You Convert
Bring these items to a coordinated financial and tax review:
- Current account statements and prior Forms 8606 documenting after-tax IRA contributions.
- Projected income, deductions, spending, and cash available for conversion taxes.
- Expected pension, Social Security, and RMD income, plus planned investment sales.
- Medicare timing, beneficiary goals, and the custodian’s conversion deadline.
The most useful Roth conversion strategies begin with a clear picture of your household’s next several years.
Align Your Roth Conversion Strategy with Your Retirement Goals
Roth conversions involve important decisions about taxes, retirement income, and your financial future. Our team can help you evaluate how a Roth conversion fits into your broader financial picture and long-term goals.
Frequently Asked Questions About Roth Conversion Rules
Income limits for direct Roth IRA contributions do not prevent an eligible conversion, and annual contribution limits do not cap the conversion amount. Workplace plan rules can restrict when you may move 401(k) assets.
The previously untaxed portion generally becomes ordinary income. If you made nondeductible IRA contributions, the Form 8606 calculation generally allocates after-tax basis proportionately across your traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRAs. You cannot simply select only the after-tax dollars.
For a direct conversion in a calendar tax year, complete the transfer by December 31, allowing for your custodian’s processing deadline. Unlike annual IRA contributions, you cannot designate a spring conversion for the prior year. You generally cannot reverse a completed conversion.
You cannot convert an RMD; satisfy the applicable RMD first. Withdrawal treatment depends on your age and the Roth IRA five-year rules. Qualified earnings withdrawals generally require five tax years plus age 59½ or another qualifying condition. Separately, each conversion has a five-year clock for potential early-distribution penalties, generally relevant before 59½.
